I completely finished the whole pin set after trying since the release. Godhead was the final one missed. I’ve order many shirts and they all been above expectations. Thanks for being an awesome group of people.

I’ve purchased the mystery pin set before, in fact maybe a month prior to this one. The 2 sets had the exact same 5 pins in it. The pins themselves are great (albeit questionable quality with the pin backings), but the randomness of the sets feels deceitful.

If you got a set, probably give it a few months at least before trying again and save yourself the burden of trying to get a refund

The pins were really well made but it looks like they weren't stored well before being sold. There is some slight discoloration (yellowing of white colors) that appear on any pin with white in it. It's not incredible noticeable but still a flaw nevertheless. Otherwise a well made and great product.

Bought 5 packs for a total of 25 pins and they were all duplicates. Very disappointed. Hoping support can help me in some capacity. It's not like I can trade locally since Isaac super fans aren't abundant... Even moreso with pins to trade.

Why not make a complete pack? How do you get the 26th pin if there's 5 in a pack? Doesn't make sense to me unless there's a pack with 6 pins for some odd reason.

High quality, got the ones i wanted!

I bought these around a year ago and got more this year for a Christmas gift. They came in the smallest little black plastic bag and not in a presentable box. Very disappointed with the quality of the packaging, does not reflect the price of the item.

I like the pins mostly dry baby

I like the pins but I didn’t get any of the ones I wanted :,) wish there was a way to get specific pins I wanted like 5 or so specific ones but I didn’t see an option to pick specific ones only random ones which kinda sucked

Packages are missing and I'm still waiting for a response. There are no instructions on how to file a claim and I may just need to resort to having my bank stepping in and helping.

Look great!